How to Protect Product Experience When Ingredients Change

Author profile picture

Phiala Mehring, Sensory Experience Director

13 Nov, 2026 | 5 minutes

There was a lot of challenging weather this year, and with El Niño, there is still potential for some more extreme weather. But our changing climate isn’t the only thing which is impacting the supply of food and drink ingredients. In fact, supply-chain resilience has become one of those phrases we hear almost daily. Beyond the substantial implications of climate change, crop disease, geopolitics, regulatory rules and price volatility are all putting ingredients under pressure. And one of the clearest examples is quite possibly sitting in your fridge. 

Orange juice has been squeezed by weather extremes and citrus greening disease in some of the world's biggest growing regions, and one forecast has global orange juice production down 13% for 2026/27. This is not a one-off; it is a year-by-year trend.  

With these kinds of challenges, brands are having to adapt. 

Squeezing orange juice

Some are blending in mandarin, apple or other fruit, and some are using less orange juice altogether, supported by flavor technologies. In the full knowledge that cutting the juice can create taste and textural challenges which is why their toolboxes include ways to lift the perception of sweetness, mask acidity and bitterness, and bring back mouthfeel. This sensory engineering (and that is exactly what it is) is designed to ensure that product experiences are protected and, as far as possible, remain consistent. But in reality, it is bigger than that. 

If you are pouring yourself a glass of orange juice (OJ), you are probably not really thinking about the origin of the oranges (granted you may have done that at point of purchase). You might not even be thinking about what you are expecting from your glass of OJ in sensory terms. However, you will have a ‘template’ in your head. What the OJ will look like as you pour it into your glass, the aroma as it pours, the balance of sweet and sharp, the body in the mouth and how it finishes. If the OJ you are drinking differs from that template, you’ll probably notice. And that is super important. 

So, what happens when ingredients change or become unavailable? The obvious response to ingredient pressure is to build ingredient resilience (much easier to type than implement!). Another supplier, another origin, another variety, a reformulation. All completely sensible. But it's not the only way, and in some respects, we are missing sensory tricks here. Why? Because there is another layer. Ingredient resilience isn't enough. We need SENSORY resilience too.

If an ingredient changes, the natural instinct is to find the closest replacement, and sensory science can certainly tell you how close A is to B. But an ingredient rarely contributes one isolated attribute. It's part of a system, and changing one part of that system can shift appearance, aroma, flavor, texture, breakdown and after-feel elsewhere, which unfolds over time. 

In addition, not every attribute carries equal weight. Perhaps the balance between sweet and sharp is non-negotiable. In fact, in my sensory experience, I would say that it IS non-negotiable; there is no ‘perhaps’ about it. There is a consequential temporal dimension to that balance.  Not to mention how it interacts with other parts of the product experience, setting up perceptions of freshness or otherwise.  

Other elements of drinking OJ don’t necessarily play such an important role; sensory characteristics that, if they change, don’t have a major impact on the experience of drinking OJ. 

And there you were thinking that OJ was simple! 

Sensory resilience starts with understanding the architecture of the experience rather than the ingredient list. It separates what needs protecting, what has permission to move and, interestingly, what might even be improved.  

We have seen this work well with other products. PepsiCo says that when it cut salt and fat in Doritos in Europe, it kept several recipe routes open and chose the one that best connected with the brand promise. That's a company account, of course, but notice what it did. It identified the experiences that mattered and designed them in. That is creating sensory resilience through careful sensory design. The potential impact of regulatory changes is reduced through the use of sensory science. 

If you are trying to adapt to ingredient changes and supply chain challenges, then you need to think at the level of the experience rather than just ingredients. You need to be thinking about sensory design and using that to create sensory resilience, not just ingredient resilience.

For established brands, the stakes are really quite high. Consumers carry sensory memories of them, which is an enormously valuable asset and can make reformulation unforgiving. And with disease, weather and cost pressures showing no sign of going away, ingredient volatility is becoming normal rather than exceptional. 

That changes the role of sensory science. Too often we're brought in when procurement or R&D already has three substitutes and wants to know which tastes closest. I'd rather we helped define the problem BEFORE ingredient selection begins. What experience are we protecting? Which cues create recognition? How do they unfold over time? Where is variation acceptable, and where might change make things better? 

At MMR, our trained panels profile the current product and the alternatives side by side, attribute by attribute and across the consumption experience, so our client teams can see how much change the experience can absorb. Alongside consumer research, which tells us why those attributes matter, this gives formulators a much broader space to work in. 

Supply-chain resilience keeps ingredients flowing. Formulation resilience keeps products manufacturable. But consumers don't buy supply chains or formulations. They buy experiences. Sensory resilience is what makes sure those experiences survive, even when the ingredients behind them don't. 

So, if a key ingredient disappeared tomorrow, would you know exactly which part of the experience to protect? Drop us a line, and we can talk more.